win it for the world

150 years ago this week a Richmond paper reprinted that part of a piece by the New York Herald that wondered what would happen if Lieutenant General Grant actually failed in the upcoming Virginia campaign. Factionalism might possibly keep the United States from its rightful place as a world power for another hundred years. Despotism around the world would be strengthened, and “the great republic of modern times” would not be able to fulfill its destiny of influencing the progress of the humanity. Sam Grant had the weight of the world on his shoulders?

From the Richmond Daily Dispatch May 4, 1864:

The effect of Grant’s failure in the coming campaign.

The New York Herald hasn’t yet mustered the courage to say that Grant’s failure in Virginia will end the war, but it is very clear that [ that ] opinion prevails in Yankeedom. It draws a pleasing picture of where the “United States” would be placed in the eyes of foreign nations if it should win the fight, and with it the war, but says:

But if Grant should fall it is hardly possible to say what results may not follow. We would be loth to recognize even such a defeat as the death blow of our cause. It is certain that the staunch qualities of our people, taken as a whole, would lead them to rally for even a greater struggle still. But it is also certain that such a defeat would strengthen immensely the factions that exist in our midst, and political anarchy would blunt the edge of all our future attempts. And thus it is at least probable that this defeat might lead to events that would count us out, for a hundred years, from the number of great nations. One great disruption would lead to lesser ones; we would be broken up into a community of petty and quarrelsome States, and the great experiment of free government that we have so magnificently tried for eighty years would be settled against the people. We would die the youngest of great republics, and our fall would strengthen the hands of despotic power everywhere.

It thus appears that the struggle upon which we are now about to enter is a momentous one, not only to ourselves but to the world at large. Its result either way will affect for good or evil the future history of the human race. It is as distinct a turning point in human history as were the battles of Marathon, of Tours, of Pultowa, or Waterloo. At Marathon the possession of Europe was decided against the despot who grasped all Asia. At Tours it was determined whether Mohammedanism or Christianity should prevail in Europe. Pultowa brought Russia into the council of European nations, and necessitated a new balance of power; and Water[loo] decided the possession of Europe against the people and in favor of the little coterie of kings that constituted the Holy Alliance. Our coming battle is to decide issues as great as any of these, since it is to determine whether the great republic of modern times shall stand or fall — determine the existence of a Government destined to exert a greater influence on the progress of the human race than any other known to history. The responsibilities of the man who commands our armies in this great crisis are tremendous, and the reward of his success will be the greatest within the gift of the people.

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Military Matters, Northern Society, Overland Campaign | Tagged , | Leave a comment

no more fiddling

William Meade Dame, D.D.

march like a terrapin – Private Dame

I’ve heard it said that, in general, we should trust sources closest to the date of a historical event. People can lie any time, but our memory sure can play tricks as time moves on and on. Here a member of the First Company of the Richmond Howitzers remembers, with the help of his journals, May 2, 1864 – about 55 years after the fact. Any luxuries accumulated over the winter had to be sent to Richmond via Orange Court House – the Federals were starting to move.

From From the Rapidan to Richmond and the Spottsylvania Campaign by William Meade Dame, D.D. (pages 63-65).

Nineteen miles from Orange Court House, Virginia, the road running northeast into Culpeper crosses “Morton’s Ford”” of the Rapidan River, which, just now, lay between the Federal “Army of the Potomac” and the Confederate “Army of Northern Virginia.”

As this road approaches within three-fourths of a mile of the river it rises over a sharp hill, and, thence, winds its way down the hill to the Ford. On the ridge, just where the road crosses it, the guns of the “First Richmond Howitzers” were in position, commanding the Ford; and the Howitzer Camp was to the right of the road, in the pine wood just back of the ridge. Here, we had been on picket all the winter, helping the infantry pickets to watch the enemy and guard the Ford.

One bright sunny morning, the 2d of May, 1864, a courier rode into the Howitzer Camp. We had been expecting him, and knew at once that “something was up.” The soldier instinct and long experience told us that it was about time for something to turn up. The long winter had worn away; the sun and winds, of March and April, had made the roads firm again. Just across the river lay the great army, which was only waiting for this, to make another desperate push for Richmond, and we were there for the particular purpose of making that push vain.

For some days we had seen great volumes of smoke rising, in various directions, across the river, and heard bands playing, and frequent volleys of firearms, over in the Federal Camp. Everybody knew what all this meant, so we had been looking for that courier.

Soon after we reached the Captain’s tent, orders were given to pack up whatever we could not carry on the campaign, and in two hours, a wagon would leave, to take all this stuff to Orange Court House; thence it would be taken to Richmond and kept for us, until next winter.

Unidentified soldier in Richmond Howitzers uniform (between 1861 and 1865; LOC: LC-DIG-ppmsca-33348)

“Unidentified soldier in Richmond Howitzers uniform”

This was quickly done! The packing was not done in “Saratoga trunks,” nor were the things piles of furs and winter luxuries. The “things” consisted of whatever, above absolute necessaries, had been accumulated in winter quarters; a fiddle, a chessboard, a set of quoits, an extra blanket, or shirt, or pair of shoes, that any favored child of Fortune had been able to get hold of during the winter. Everything like this must go. It did not take long to roll all the “extras” into bundles, strap them up and pitch them into the wagon. And in less than two hours after the order was given the wagon was gone, and the men left in campaign “trim.”

This meant that each man had, left, one blanket, one small haversack, one change of underclothes, a canteen, cup and plate, of tin, a knife and fork, and the clothes in which he stood. When ready to march, the blanket, rolled lengthwise, the ends brought together and strapped, hung from left shoulder across under right arm, the haversack,—furnished with towel, soap, comb, knife and fork in various pockets, a change of underclothes in one main division, and whatever rations we happened to have, in the other,—hung on the left hip; the canteen, cup and plate, tied together, hung on the right; toothbrush, “at will,” stuck in two button holes of jacket, or in haversack; tobacco bag hung to a breast button, pipe in pocket. In this rig,—into which a fellow could get in just two minutes from a state of rest,—the Confederate Soldier considered himself all right, and ready for anything; in this he marched, and in this he fought. Like the terrapin—“all he had he carried on his back”—this all weighed about seven or eight pounds.

The extra baggage gone, all of us knew that the end of our stay here was very near, and we were all ready to pick up and go; we were on the eve of battle and everybody was on the “qui vive” for decisive orders. They quickly came!

Spring might have meant the heavy bloodletting would soon recommence, but it was also a chance for rebel soldiers to vary their diet with some gathered vegetables, any vegetables (page 59):

The winter had now worn away and the spring had come. Vegetation began to show signs of life. Its coming bore us one comfort in one way—among others. It was not so cold, and we did not have to tote so many logs of wood to keep up our fires. Down on the river flats, where vegetation showed sooner than it did on the hills, green things began to shoot up. Dandelions, sheep sorrel, poke leaves and such, though not used in civil life, were welcome to us, for they were much better than no salad at all. The men craved something green. The unbroken diet of just bread and meat—generally salt meat at that—gave some of the men scurvy. The only remedy for that was something acid, or vegetable food. The men needed this and craved it—so when the green shoots of any kind appeared we would go down on the flats, and gather up all the green stuff we could find, and boil it with the little piece of bacon we might have. It improved the health of the men very much.

The army of Northern Virginia survived the winter of 1863-64 on scant rations, but according to Mr. Dame the rations were about to get scanter (pages 72-73):

I have alluded to rations; they were scarce here, as always when any fighting was on hand. Even in camp, where all was at its best, we had for rations, per day, one and a half pints of flour, or coarse cornmeal,—ground with the cob in it we used to think,—and one-quarter of a pound of bacon, or “mess pork,” or a pound, far more often half a pound, of beef.

But, in time of a fight! Ah then, thin was the fare! That small ration dwindled until, at times, eating was likely to become a “lost art.” I have seen a man, Bill Lewis, sit down and eat three days’ rations at one time. He said “He did not want the trouble of carrying it, and he did want one meal occasionally that wasn’t an empty form.” The idea seemed to be that a Confederate soldier would fight exactly in proportion as he didn’t eat. And his business was to fight. This theory was put into practice on a very close and accurate calculation; with the odds that, as a rule, we had against us, in the battles of the Army of Northern Virginia, we had to meet two or three to one. Then, each Confederate soldier was called upon to be equal to two or three Federal soldiers, and, therefore, each Confederate must have but one-half or one-third the rations of a Federal soldier. It was easy figuring, and so it was arranged in practice.

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Confederate States of America, Military Matters, Overland Campaign | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

+ Burnside

The rebels are realizing General Grant is going to have even more troops as the inevitable campaign soon begins.

From the Richmond Daily Dispatch May 2, 1864:

From Northern Virginia.

Orange C. H.April 30.

–Our scouts report that Burnside has arrived at Alexandria preparatory to going to Grant.

[second Dispatch.]

Orange, C H., May 1.

–Burnside has certainly arrived at Alexandria, and is moving rapidly to form a junction with Grant in Culpeper. Reports from the enemy’s lines state that there is great activity in their camps, as if concentrating in Culpeper. The impression is general here that Grant will advance this week.

The roads are dry and hard, the weather fine, and our troops in excellent plight every way.

General Burnside would have started his Ninth Corps from Annapolis, where he ordered the march, even though he had reportedly requested more time. From The New-York Times April 26, 1864:

IMPORTANT FROM ANNAPOLIS.; An order form Gen. Burnside–The Ninth Army Corps About to Move.

WASHIHGTON, Monday, April 25.

The Annapolis Republican, of Saturday, contains the following:

HEADQUARTERS OF THE NINTH ARMY CORPS, ANNAPOLIS, Md., April 19, 1864.

CIRCULAR No. 3. — This army being on the eve of a movement, no applications for leaves of absence or furloughs for any length of time will be granted, excepting only in those cases where there is evidence that the reasons are of the most urgent character. No notice will be taken of any others.

By command of Maj.-Gen. BURNSIDE.

LEWIS RICHMOND, Assistant Adjutant-General.

The Republican says:

“Gen. BURNSIDE has ordered, we understand, all the troops now on the way to join him, and we also hear that he has asked the Government for further time to gather more men.

Another report says there will be no expedition from Annapolis, but that these troops are here as a Reserve Corps.

But all surmisings are now at an end, as the troops are to move to-day.”

As the fighting started the Ninth Corps would be with the Army of the Potomac but not of the Army of the Potomac because Burnside outranked Meade.

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Military Matters, Overland Campaign | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

straddle

Elmira rendezvous, long may it wave (1864 or 1865; LOC: LC-DIG-ppmsca-11326)

meeting place, holding place

It’s May 1st somewhere …

Since the beginning of the war Elmira served as a rendezvous point for New York soldiers heading south. Here’s evidence that Union soldier miscreants were also confined there and that Confederate prisoners would soon be on the way.

From a Seneca County, New York newspaper in April 1864:

SOLDIERS AT ELMIRA. – The Gazette says there were 1579 men in the Barracks at Elmira, on Thursday of last week, of which 200 were under arrest for various causes – 82 were sick.

Also from a Seneca County newspaper sometime in April 1864:

TO BE EXECUTED. – A soldier named STEWART, who is under the sentence of death for poisoning his guards at Elmira, is to be executed to-day. His death warrant was read to him on Friday last.

From a Seneca County, New York newspaper sometime in May 1864:

REBEL PRISONERS AT ELMIRA. – The Elmira papers state that orders have been received by the military authorities there, from Washington, for the accomodation [sic] of 11,000 rebel prisoners, who are to be quartered in that place.

The first 400 of over 12,000 rebel prisoners arrived on July 6th.

Elmira Prison (http://www.loc.gov/item/001-ocm47772821/)

shape of things to come (by Rebel prisoner David J. Coffman of the 7th Virginia Cavalry)

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Month, Civil War prisons, Military Matters, Northern Society | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

aiding and abedding

Desperation sure can lead to some creativity. Here a soldier and his friends used a “novel mode” to try to escape the military, but the Confederate authorities eventually got their man. The Richmond paper reminded their readers about the high penalties for helping deserters. At least in this case, the deserter himself was punished by being sent back to the service.

From the Richmond Daily Dispatch April 29, 1864:

Local Matters.

Harboring a deserter.

–A novel mode of screening deserters from arrest was disclosed before Commissioner A. H. Sands a day or two since. There being some suspicion that a man named J. H. A. Bowlar, a deserter from the Confederate service, was about the premises of Mrs. Louisa Lankford, living in Screamersville, a guard was dispatched to search her house. In one of the rooms was a bed on which were two females who claimed to be very sick; but having instituted a fruitless search about every other part of the house, and there being some doubts in their minds as to the truth of the statement made by the professed invalids, the officers of the law insisted upon examining the bed upon which they lay, when Bowlar was found between two beds, on the top one of which were the two women. Getting wind of the approach of the guard, the above mentioned mode was adopted as the one most likely to shield him from detection. The discovery, however, was a lucky one for Bowlar, for when rescued from his hiding place he was in a very exhausted state, and had he remained there much longer in all probability he would have suffocated.

The parties were committed by the Commissioner to Castle Thunder. Subsequently Bowlar was tried by Court Martial, the verdict of which body was that he should be drummed out of the service and afterwards conscribed for another branch of the service.

The penalty for harboring deserters.

–As many persons are not aware of the penalty laid down for harboring deserters from the Confederate service, the following section passed by the last Congress is published for general information:

“The Congress of the Confederate States of America do enact. That every person not subject to the rules and articles of war, who shall procure or entice a soldier, or person enrolled for service in the army of the Confederate States, to desert, or who shall aid or assist any deserter from the army, or any person enrolled for service, to evade their proper commanders, or to prevent their arrest to be returned to the service, or who shall knowingly conceal or harbor any such deserter, or shall purchase from any soldier or person enrolled for service any portion of his arms, equipments, rations, or clothing, or any property belonging to the Confederate States, or any officer or soldier of the Confederate States, shall, upon conviction before the District Court of the Confederate States having jurisdiction of the offence, confined not exceeding one thousand dollars, and be imprisoned not exceeding two years.”

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Month, Confederate States of America, Southern Society | Tagged | Leave a comment

brief furlough

From a Seneca County, New York newspaper in April 1864:

AT HOME. – Lieut. WM. VAN RENSSELEAR of the 50th Engineer Regiment, is at home on a brief furlough.

William V. Rensselear

William V. Rensselear

Brandy Station, Virginia. View of the camp of the 50th New York Engineers from the northwest (by Timothy H. O'Sullivan; April 1864; LOC: LC-DIG-cwpb-00731)

50th New York Engineers’ camp at Brandy Station, April 1864

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Month, Military Matters | Tagged , | Leave a comment

guano gone

Statue of Rear Admiral Raphael Semmes, Mobile, Alabama (by Carol M. Highsmith, 2010 March 17; LOC:  LC-DIG-highsm-05248)

guano captured (statue in Mobile, Alabama)

The CSS Alabama is still at work disrupting commerce on the high seas. Here’s how Raphael Semmes, the ship’s commander, remembered the pursuit and capture of a boat full of fertilizer 150 years ago this week.

From Memoirs of Service Afloat, During the War Between the States (1869) (pages 748-749) by Raphael Semmes:

On the 22d of April, having reached the track of the homeward-bound Pacific ships of the enemy, we descried an unlucky Yankee, to whom we immediately gave chase. The chase continued the whole night, the moon shining brightly, the breeze being gentle, and the sea smooth. The Yankee worked like a good fellow to get away, piling clouds of canvas upon his ship, and handling her with the usual skill, but it was of no use. When the day dawned we were within a couple of miles of him. It was the old spectacle of the panting, breathless fawn, and the inexorable stag-hound. A gun brought his colors to the peak, and his main-yard to the mast. The prize proved to be the ship Rockingham, from Callao, bound to Cork for orders. Her cargo consisted of guano from the Chincha Islands, and there was an attempt to protect it. It was shipped by the “Guano Consignment Company of Great Britain.” Among the papers was a certificate, of which the following is the purport: One Joseph A. Danino, who signs for Danino & Moscosa, certifies that the guano belongs to the Peruvian Government; and Her Britannic Majesty’s Consul at Lima, certifies that the said Joseph A. Danino appeared before him, and “voluntarily declared, that the foregoing signature is of his own handwriting, and also, that the cargo above mentioned is truly and verily the property of the Peruvian Government.” This was about equal to some of the Yankee attempts, that have been noticed, to cover cargoes. With the most perfect unconcern for the laws of nations, no one swore to anything. Mr. Danino certified, and the Consul certified that Mr. Danino had certified. Voila tout! We transferred to the Alabama such stores and provisions as we could make room for, and the weather being fine, we made a target of the prize, firing some shot and shell into her with good effect; and at five P. M. we burned her, and filled away on our course.

"The Pirate 'Alabama,' Alias '290,' Certified to be correct by Captain Hagar of the 'Brilliant'"  Line engraving published in "Harper's Weekly", 1862, depicting CSS Alabama burning a prize.  U.S. Naval Historical Center Photograph.

“inexorable stag-hound” in 1862

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Confederate States of America, Naval Matters | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Sunday drive

Lieut. Gen. U.S. Grant. (Cincinnati : Lith. & publd. by Donaldson & Elmes, c1864; LOC:  LC-DIG-pga-01054 )

“natural qualities of a high order”

150 years ago today General Meade provided another balanced assessment of his new boss.

From The Life and Letters of George Gordon Meade … (page 191):

HEADQUARTERS ARMY OF THE POTOMAC, April 24, 1864.

Cram and John Cadwalader arrived yesterday afternoon. To-day Cram went to church with me, where we heard an excellent from a Mr. Adams, a distinguished Presbyterian clergyman from New York. After church I drove Cram and Cadwalader to Culpeper, where we paid a visit to General Grant. After coming away, I plainly saw that Cram was disappointed. Grant is not a striking man, is very reticent, has never mixed with the world, and has but little manner, indeed is somewhat ill at ease in the presence of strangers; His early education was undoubtedly very slight; in fact, I fancy his West Point course was pretty much all the education he ever had, as since his graduation I don’t believe he has read or studied any. At the same time, he has natural qualities of a high order, and is a man whom, the more you see and know him, the better you like him. He puts me in mind of old Taylor, and sometimes I fancy he models himself on old Zac.

Yesterday I sent my orderly with Old Baldy to Philadelphia. He will never be fit again for hard service, and I thought he was entitled to better care than could be given to him on the march. …

Well, there is evidence that Old Baldy was with General Meade on the upcoming march.

Cram was probably Mrs. Meade’s brother-in-law.

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Military Matters, Overland Campaign | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

lookout

Clark's Mountain and vicinity )by Robert knox Sneden)

by Robert Knox Sneden

From the Richmond Daily Dispatch April 23 1864:

From Northern Virginia.

Orange C. H., April 23d.

–Observations from Clark’s Mountain disclose no change in the Yankee camps. It is reported that the enemy will begin to-day moving up their rear, preparatory to an advance. Nothing is going on in our front indicating an immediate advance. The roads are dry and hard. The weather beautiful.

Meanwhile people in Richmond could read that the new man in charge of those Yankees was considered a second-rate blunderer by some in the North and by a French critic.

From the Richmond Daily Dispatch April 22, 1864:

G.P. Cluseret, born France (between 1860 and 1870; LOC: LC-DIG-cwpb-04620)

everyone’s a critic (Gustave Paul Cluseret)

Gen. Grant.

–Among military men at the North Grant is not regarded as a genius. The new Fremont organ in New York, the New Nation, devotes a considerable space in every issue to a denunciation of the policy which has placed the whole military operations of the Federals in the control of a “second-rate General.” One General Cluseret, an old French army officer, now in the Federal service, writes a series of articles to this paper on Grant. He shows that Grant blundered for months over an unnecessary canal, opposite Vicksburg, wasting thousands of lives thereby, and abandoning the project eventually; that the victory at Chattanooga was due to the previous disposition of the Federal troops by General Rosecrans, and that General Buell really commanded at Shiloh. General Cluseret pronounces Rosecrans the only eminent military genius in the Federal army. Just now Rosecrans is on the retired list for his Chickamauga disaster.

You can see a view from Clark’s Mountain here.

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Military Matters, Overland Campaign | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Flanders … again?

NY Times 4-23-1864

NY Times 4-23-1864

150 years ago this week a Northern paper expressed surprise that General Grant would focus his attention on the worn-out Virginia theater. After all, the new Commander-in-Chief of all the Union armies was from out west, where most the momentum was in 1863.

From The New-York Times April 23, 1864:

THE ARMY OF THE POTOMAC.; THE CAMPAIGN TOWARD RICHMOND. Grant Against Lee.

WASHINGTON, Thursday, April 21, 1864.

The outlines of the Summer campaign are assuming a form that belies all the anticipations of the military critics. Nothing has been more confidently expected than that the main opera- tions would continue on the grand strategic lines of the Southwest, where the magnificent territorial conquests of the Summer and Winter of 1863 remain to be completed and crowned by an advance from Chattanooga into the States of the Gulf. Indeed, he would have been a bold prophet who would, two months ago, have predicted that the restricted, and it was thought, exhausted, battle ground of Virginia — the Flanders of our war — would resume the old military primacy it held during the early stages of the war, and all other armies would be held in abeyance and forced to send their tributary troops to swell the Army of the Potomac, and that the conqueror of the Mississippi, now the General-in-Chief of all the armies of the union, would transfer his tent to the banks of the Rapidan.

Yet such is the simple statement of the actual situation. When NAPOLEON was carrying on simultaneous operations in Italy and Germany, the army into which he threw the reinforcement of his presence became immediately the principal army; the other and its operations became subordinate and subsidiary. So, had GRANT remained at Chattanooga, as was expected, the Summer battle-fields would have been in Tennessee; but having vaulted into Virginia, the Army of the Potomac is now the cynosure of all eyes. The present preparations give promise that a series of operations will soon be initiated, the most formidable, the most exciting and the most intense of the war — the most formidable in respect to the proportions of the contending forces, the most exciting on account of the skill of the two great players pitted against each other, and the most intense and obstinate on account of the immediate stake at issue, and the vastness of the ulterior results that must come from this colossal passage at arms.

Gen. GRANT aims to take Richmond and destroy the army of LEE, which is, and has been the head and front of all the power and prestige of the rebel cause. …

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Military Matters, Overland Campaign | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment